Difference between revisions of "Voting"
(→Voting in elections) |
|||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
Finally, it is technically possible to do a roll call vote, though it is the [[Chair]]'s prerogative to declare a request for such a vote [[dilatory]]. | Finally, it is technically possible to do a roll call vote, though it is the [[Chair]]'s prerogative to declare a request for such a vote [[dilatory]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Voting on a motion is guaranteed to [[terminate]] as the Chair isn't going to put up with it for long. | ||
===Voting in elections=== | ===Voting in elections=== | ||
| Line 61: | Line 63: | ||
Here we have both Barry and Chuck in a single tier. Their total number of votes is greater than one third, but because at least one tier must always be removed, they are both removed from running, and Abe wins. | Here we have both Barry and Chuck in a single tier. Their total number of votes is greater than one third, but because at least one tier must always be removed, they are both removed from running, and Abe wins. | ||
| − | + | Finally, in the case of an n-way tie, where n is the number of candidates remaining, an additional round will be run. If the next round results in a tie, the winner will be determined by random process. | |
| − | + | Voting in an election is guaranteed to terminate as at least one candidate is removed every round, except in the case that all candidates tie, where voting is decided by [[divine providence]]. This [[Byzantine]] voting procedure was devised by committee after the previous Byzantine voting procedure was determined through experiment to be interminable. | |
Wasn't that fun! | Wasn't that fun! | ||
Latest revision as of 22:19, 28 April 2007
KGB's Voting rules represent a subtle and sublime science. The method of voting varies depending on context.
Voting on motions
Voting on motions is conducted by whomever is the Chair of the meeting. The generally approved method of voting is to request that members vote by undertaking some action or vocalization related to the subject matter of the motion.
There are certain problems with this method of voting. In particular, it can often be difficult to determine which side won when everyone in the room is flailing around. In that case, a request for a hand vote would be appropriate.
If the Chair is in a hurry, it is also possible to undertake a vote by acclamation, whereby the motion passes unless someone objects.
Finally, it is technically possible to do a roll call vote, though it is the Chair's prerogative to declare a request for such a vote dilatory.
Voting on a motion is guaranteed to terminate as the Chair isn't going to put up with it for long.
Voting in elections
The voting methodology used in elections is significantly more complex than that used for motions.
First, the color of elections is purple.
Second, voting is conducted by secret ballot.
Third, the voting is administered by electron proctors.
Each officer position is elected separately. In each round of voting, the votes are tallied and then divided into "tiers" of candidates with the same number of votes. The tiers of candidates with the least number of votes are removed from the running until at least one third of the votes have been removed. At least one tier must always be removed. If there remains more than one candidate another round of the election is run. Vote, count, repeat.
An example is in order. Consider an election for President where the candidates are Abe, Barry, Chuck, Dave, and Ed. In the first round of voting, the breakdown is as follows:
| A | 8 |
| B | 7 |
| C | 7 |
| D | 6 |
| E | 5 |
In the first round of voting, Ed is removed from the running first, being in the tier with the lowest number of votes. This is five of the total thirty-three, and is less than a third. Dave's tier is removed then, bringing the total removed votes to 11, which reaches the one third threshold. This leaves Abe, Barry, and Chuck for the next round.
| A | 13 |
| B | 10 |
| C | 10 |
Here we have both Barry and Chuck in a single tier. Their total number of votes is greater than one third, but because at least one tier must always be removed, they are both removed from running, and Abe wins.
Finally, in the case of an n-way tie, where n is the number of candidates remaining, an additional round will be run. If the next round results in a tie, the winner will be determined by random process.
Voting in an election is guaranteed to terminate as at least one candidate is removed every round, except in the case that all candidates tie, where voting is decided by divine providence. This Byzantine voting procedure was devised by committee after the previous Byzantine voting procedure was determined through experiment to be interminable.
Wasn't that fun!
